City Boy Coffee Review 2026

City Boy Coffee is a New York City specialty coffee roastery founded in 2020 by Matt Falber, a performer-turned-coffee expert who discovered specialty coffee while traveling and performing Off-Broadway. Roasted in small batches at their facility in Long Island City, Queens, the brand has quickly built a reputation for sourcing rare, high-scoring single-origin coffees from around the world with a strong commitment to quality and pricing transparency.

The roastery's lineup includes standout offerings such as a Madagascar Yellow & Red Bourbon, a Peru Gesha: Guardian del Bosque at $27.50, Ethiopian Coffee: Banko Gotiti at $26.00, and a Kenyan Coffee: Kangunu FCS at $24.00. All coffees sold by City Boy score at least 84 on the Specialty Coffee Association scale, with most targeting 87 or above. Notably, their Zambia Katheshi Estate Anaerobic Natural was rated 94 points by Coffee Review and ranked #20 on Coffee Review's Top 50 Coffees of 2025. They have also won multiple Golden Bean awards for both coffee and espresso.

A flagship offering is the Sphere Coffee Club, a monthly subscription that has featured single-origin coffees from more than 50 countries across Africa, Latin America, Asia, and beyond. Subscribers can choose month-to-month or prepaid 3-, 6-, or 12-month plans. Each month's selection is intentionally chosen to contrast with the previous, exposing members to new processing methods, varietals, and flavor profiles. This makes it an excellent option for anyone looking to systematically develop their coffee palate.

Beyond retail coffee, City Boy Coffee offers events and catering services including espresso catering, barista staffing, and coffee tasting classes held at their Long Island City roastery. They also maintain a wholesale program for businesses and publish a Pricing Transparency page detailing exactly what they paid farmers, reflecting their founding commitment to fair compensation throughout the supply chain. The brand is NGLCC Certified as an LGBT Business Enterprise and holds a Made in NYC certification.

City Boy Coffee ships across the United States. Their return policy does not allow returns on perishable coffee products, but customers who experience an issue are encouraged to contact support within one week of receiving their order for a case-by-case resolution. The store also offers a loyalty program, a referral program, and an affiliate program, providing multiple ways for repeat customers to earn rewards and savings.